Mystery Baseball

Out of stock

Out of stock for now, but the game isn’t over! Sign up and we’ll email you as soon as this set is back in stock.

I agree that my email will be used in order to notify me when the product is back in stock.


(5 customer reviews)

$24.99

Product temporarily out of stock.

Baseball Mystery Boxes—Sold by brick and mortar stores by the individual box and sold on Amazon by the case.—Each case contains 24 individually boxed Baseball Guys.

  • Great to use as party favors! Purchase the box of 24 so you can offer each guest one or two boxes when they leave!
  • Size of player is 2.5 inches.
  • There is one of five possible players included in each similarly designed box. It’s a mystery!
  • The 5 different possible players are: Pitcher, Catcher, Runner, Fielder, Batter.
  • Sold by the case.

 

  • Fun addition to an Easter basket or Christmas stocking.
  • Perfect size to bring in your purse to entertain any young sports fan on the plane, in a car or at a restaurant!

Additional information

Weight 1.75 lbs

5 reviews for Mystery Baseball

  1. Anonymous
    March 15, 2026
    Encourages imaginative play!
    This is the 4th sport set I bought for my grandson! It is not unlike him to have multiple sports set up in the family room at the same time!
    Anonymous
    Child's Age: 5 and 7
    December 10, 2025
    Wonderful idea!
    I've loved Strat-o-Matic Baseball since I was just about in junior high. But, it's just too complicated for my 5-year old son. He's also got the atten...More
    I've loved Strat-o-Matic Baseball since I was just about in junior high. But, it's just too complicated for my 5-year old son. He's also got the attention span of a flea, so watching a game of baseball is difficult for him. In other words, he doesn't have that solid understanding of how the game works.

    When I saw Baseball Guys I was intrigued. When I saw it didn't come with rules, it all made sense and the light bulb went off.

    I made some simple rules, well far more simpler than Strat-o-Matic. Basically, you roll a d6 for balls/strikes/hits. If you get a hit, you roll a 2d6 to find the base. If you do get on base, the defense gets a 2d6 roll to see if they can get you out or not. This way, both teams get to participate in each half of the inning.

    My 5 and 7 year olds love the field and players and the rules I've made. The best part is they love swapping their defense on and off the field at each half-inning, so they're really learning the game and each player participates on the field.
    Anonymous
    October 12, 2025
    Thank you
    Grandsons loved this. Play it often when they come over. Good quality pieces.
    Anonymous
    Child's Age: 6
    September 12, 2025
    GREAT toy! My son loves it!!
    We got this set of Baseball Guys for our almost 6 year old son for Christmas. He's a huge baseball fanatic, and this toy was perfect for him. He'd bee...More
    We got this set of Baseball Guys for our almost 6 year old son for Christmas. He's a huge baseball fanatic, and this toy was perfect for him. He'd been using his superhero guys to play baseball so he was ecstatic to be able to use real baseball guys. The only thing that would make this set better would be to have moveable joints to position the players however he wants them. His 7th birthday was just on Jan 22, and we just had a baseball party at an indoor batting cage, and of course the cake was a baseball diamond with 5 of these baseball guys on top! I almost think he picked the theme to his party based on having these guys on a cake! The Kaskey Kids company has terrific customer service too. Our set came without an umpire, and when I e-mailed them about this, they immediately sent one out to us. You don't see great customer service like this anymore, so it was greatly appreciated.

    I highly recommend buying from Kaskey Kids, and this set in particular. Great for letting kid's imaginations run wild.
    Anonymous
    July 19, 2025
    The Great Occupier Among them All
    Great set of figures for kids to play with. I can still remember playing with my set of plastic army men when I was small. All of my kids absolutely l...More
    Great set of figures for kids to play with. I can still remember playing with my set of plastic army men when I was small. All of my kids absolutely love sports and we wondered if he would like this set for a gift. No doubt, he does. He carries it everywhere. When our older boys are playing basketball or baseball, he is in the stands playing with each of the action figures and using his imagination. The toys are big enough where I am not worried about a choking hazard, but small enough to fit in the box and not be a chore to lug around. They have two separate teams within the box with plenty of action figures to make up their own scenarios. The scoreboard is able to be changed with innings and score, which makes it even more fun for the kids. I would likely recommend ages 4-9yo as likely best age for gift. I know they have a football and basketball kit also as our boys saw another boy playing with one in the stands before we ended up buying one.

Add a review